Best Scar Treatment

Annabelle Evans

By Annabelle Evans

| Updated 3 Days Ago

  • Scars are a natural part of healing, but they can impact both appearance and self-confidence. Whether from surgery, injury, or skin conditions, scar treatment products aim to reduce their visibility and improve skin texture. Available in creams, gels, sheets, and oils, these treatments work best when matched to the type of scar and its age, with newer scars often responding better. Key ingredients like silicone, vitamin E, and onion extract each help fade scars and smooth skin in different ways. When choosing a scar treatment, consider ease of use and safety, especially if you have sensitive skin. Some treatments require multiple applications daily, while others can be left on overnight. We tested various products to find the most effective and easy-to-use options for different scar types.

  • Mederma PM Scar Cream

    10

    We think this overnight scar cream is a top choice for those looking to fade scars while they sleep.

    10

    We think this overnight scar cream is a top choice for those looking to fade scars while they sleep.

    Pros

    • Works while you sleep
    • Shows results in 2 weeks
    • Recommended by doctors

    Cons

    • May take time to see changes
    • Needs regular use
    • Only for nighttime use

    We tried Mederma PM Scar Cream and found it easy to use. The cream spreads smoothly and doesn’t feel sticky. It has a light scent that isn’t too strong.

    After using it for a few weeks, we noticed our scars starting to look better. The cream seemed to help with both new and old scars. Acne marks and small cuts showed the most change.

    We liked that we could apply it before bed and let it work overnight. This fit well into our routine. The tube lasted a while since we only needed a small amount each time. It’s nice that it’s made for all skin types.

  • Cicatricure Scar Gel

    9.7

    We think Cicatricure Scar Gel is a solid choice for treating scars and stretch marks, thanks to its easy application and noticeable results.

    9.7

    We think Cicatricure Scar Gel is a solid choice for treating scars and stretch marks, thanks to its easy application and noticeable results.

    Pros

    • Works on old and new scars
    • Helps fade stretch marks
    • Easy to apply

    Cons

    • Strong smell
    • Takes time to see results
    • May not work for everyone

    We tried Cicatricure Scar Gel on some old scars and stretch marks. The gel felt smooth and absorbed quickly into our skin. We liked that it didn’t leave a greasy feeling behind.

    After using it for a few weeks, we noticed our scars starting to fade. The redness went down, and the texture of our skin improved. It wasn’t a miracle overnight, but we saw steady progress.

    The smell was pretty strong at first. It reminded us of teriyaki sauce, which was odd for a skin product. We got used to it after a while, but it might bother some people. We had to use it 3-4 times a day for the best results, which took some dedication. Still, for the improvements we saw, we think it’s worth the effort.

  • Bio-Oil Scar Treatment

    9.5

    We recommend Bio-Oil for its versatile skincare benefits and proven effectiveness in reducing scars and stretch marks.

    9.5

    We recommend Bio-Oil for its versatile skincare benefits and proven effectiveness in reducing scars and stretch marks.

    Pros

    • Fast-absorbing, non-greasy formula
    • Suitable for all skin types
    • Clinically proven to improve scars and stretch marks

    Cons

    • Scent may not appeal to everyone
    • Results can take time to show
    • Slightly pricey compared to basic moisturizers

    We’ve been using Bio-Oil for a while now, and we’re impressed with its skin-softening abilities. The oil feels light on the skin and absorbs quickly, leaving no greasy residue. It’s a nice change from thick creams that can clog pores.

    The blend of natural oils in Bio-Oil gives it a unique scent. We found it mild and pleasant, but some users might not love it. The oil did a great job keeping our skin hydrated throughout the day. We noticed our skin felt smoother after just a few uses.

    We tested Bio-Oil on some old scars and newer stretch marks. While it didn’t work miracles overnight, we saw gradual improvement with regular use. The oil seemed to help fade discoloration and soften the texture of scars. It’s worth noting that results can vary, and it may take weeks or months to see big changes.

  • Mederma Advanced Scar Gel

    9.4

    We think this scar gel is a solid choice for most people looking to reduce the appearance of scars, both old and new.

    9.4

    We think this scar gel is a solid choice for most people looking to reduce the appearance of scars, both old and new.

    Pros

    • Works on various scar types
    • Noticeable results in 2 weeks
    • Easy once-daily application

    Cons

    • Takes time to see full effects
    • May not work for everyone
    • Slightly pricey for the amount

    We tried Mederma Advanced Scar Gel on some old acne scars and a recent surgical scar. The gel felt nice on our skin – not sticky or greasy. It soaked in fast, which we liked.

    After two weeks of daily use, we saw some changes. The newer scar looked less red and bumpy. Our older acne marks seemed a bit lighter too. It wasn’t a huge change, but we felt good about the progress.

    The gel was simple to use. We only had to put it on once a day, which fit easily into our routine. A little went a long way, so the tube lasted longer than we expected. While it’s not cheap, we think it’s worth trying if scars bug you.

  • Psecici Scar Gel

    9.3

    We think this scar gel is a solid choice for anyone looking to improve the look of various types of scars.

    9.3

    We think this scar gel is a solid choice for anyone looking to improve the look of various types of scars.

    Pros

    • Works on many scar types
    • Absorbs quickly
    • Moisturizes skin

    Cons

    • Results may take time
    • Needs regular application
    • May not work for everyone

    We tried the Psecici Scar Gel on a few different scars and were pleased with the results. The gel has a nice, smooth texture that spreads easily on the skin. It doesn’t feel sticky or greasy, which is a big plus.

    One thing we liked was how quickly it absorbs. We didn’t have to wait around for it to dry before getting dressed. The gel also seemed to help keep our skin moisturized, which is good for scar healing.

    We used it on both new and old scars. For newer scars, we saw some improvement after about 8 weeks of use. Older scars took longer, closer to 3 months. It’s important to keep using it regularly for the best results.

    The gel worked well on different body parts, including face, arms, and legs. We found it helpful for scars from surgery, acne, and minor injuries. While it didn’t make scars vanish completely, it did make them less noticeable.

    We appreciate that this gel is safe for most skin types. It didn’t cause any irritation or breakouts when we used it. The lack of strong smell is also nice, especially when using it on the face.

  • HealFast Silicone Scar Gel

    9.1

    We think this medical-grade silicone gel is a top choice for treating various types of scars.

    9.1

    We think this medical-grade silicone gel is a top choice for treating various types of scars.

    Pros

    • Easy to apply and not sticky
    • Works on new and old scars
    • Trusted by doctors

    Cons

    • May not stay on well in high-movement areas
    • Can be pricey for long-term use
    • Results may vary depending on scar type

    We tried this scar gel on a few different scars and saw good results. The gel comes out smoothly and dries quickly, forming a thin layer over the scar. It’s not greasy or sticky, which we liked.

    One thing we noticed is that it works well on both new and old scars. We used it on a recent surgical scar and an older acne scar. After a few weeks, both scars looked less red and felt smoother.

    The gel is easy to use on faces and other visible areas. It blends in well with skin, so you can wear it during the day without anyone noticing. We found it worked best when applied twice a day.

    For scars in areas that move a lot, like knees or elbows, the gel might not stay on as well. We had to reapply it more often in these spots. It’s also a bit pricey if you need to use it for a long time.

    We think this scar gel is worth trying if you want to improve the look of scars. It’s made by doctors and uses ingredients that are proven to work. Just keep in mind that results can be different for each person and scar type.

  • Psecici Silicone Scar Sheets

    9

    We think these silicone scar sheets are a great choice for anyone looking to improve the look of their scars.

    9

    We think these silicone scar sheets are a great choice for anyone looking to improve the look of their scars.

    Pros

    • Easy to cut and apply
    • Reusable and long-lasting
    • Suitable for all skin types

    Cons

    • May not stick well in humid conditions
    • Can be visible under thin clothing
    • Results may vary depending on scar type

    We’ve been testing these Psecici scar sheets for a few weeks now, and we’re impressed with their performance. The sheets are made from medical-grade silicone, which feels soft and comfortable on the skin. We found them easy to cut to size, allowing us to treat scars of various shapes and sizes.

    One thing we really like is how well these sheets stay in place. They stuck to our skin for hours without peeling off, even during light exercise. The material is thin and flexible, so we barely noticed we were wearing them. We could go about our day without any discomfort or irritation.

    After using these sheets for a while, we noticed our scars starting to fade. The redness decreased, and the texture of the scar tissue became smoother. While results will vary from person to person, we think these sheets offer a good chance at improving the look of scars. They’re also reusable, which makes them a cost-effective option for long-term scar care.

  • AirroYE Silicone Scar Sheets

    8.7

    We think these silicone scar sheets are a solid choice for people looking to treat various types of scars effectively and comfortably.

    8.7

    We think these silicone scar sheets are a solid choice for people looking to treat various types of scars effectively and comfortably.

    Pros

    • Versatile for new and old scars
    • Comfortable and discreet
    • Reusable after washing

    Cons

    • Results may vary person to person
    • Requires consistent use
    • May not stick as well after multiple washes

    We tested these AirroYE silicone scar sheets on different scar types and were pleased with their performance. The sheets are thin and flexible, making them easy to apply to various body areas. We liked that they blend well with skin tone, so they’re not very noticeable when worn.

    During our tests, we found the sheets stayed in place well throughout the day, even during light exercise. They were comfortable to wear and didn’t cause any skin irritation. We appreciated that we could wash and reuse them a few times, which helps make them more cost-effective.

    We saw some improvement in scar appearance after a few weeks of use, though results weren’t dramatic. The sheets seemed to help reduce redness and flatten raised scars slightly. Keep in mind that scar treatment takes time, and you’ll need to use these sheets regularly for several weeks to see results.

  • ScarAway Silicone Gel

    8.7

    We think ScarAway Silicone Gel is a solid choice for most people looking to improve the appearance of scars.

    8.7

    We think ScarAway Silicone Gel is a solid choice for most people looking to improve the appearance of scars.

    Pros

    • Easy to apply and water-resistant
    • Works on various scar types
    • Suitable for sensitive skin

    Cons

    • Small tube runs out quickly
    • Takes time to see results
    • Can feel slightly sticky

    We’ve been using ScarAway Silicone Gel for a few weeks now, and we’re impressed with its ease of use. The gel goes on smoothly and dries quickly, forming a thin, clear layer over the scar. It’s not greasy, which is a big plus in our book.

    One thing we really like is how versatile this gel is. We’ve tried it on different types of scars – from surgery marks to old acne scars – and it seems to work well on all of them. The water-resistant formula is handy too. We can apply it and go about our day without worrying about it coming off.

    On the downside, the tube is pretty small. We found ourselves using it up faster than we expected, especially when treating larger scars. It also takes a while to see noticeable results – we started seeing changes after about 4 weeks of consistent use. But for those willing to stick with it, ScarAway Silicone Gel can make a real difference in scar appearance.

  • Gowgaw Scar Gel

    8.6

    We think this scar gel is a solid choice for people looking to improve the look of various types of scars.

    8.6

    We think this scar gel is a solid choice for people looking to improve the look of various types of scars.

    Pros

    • Works on both new and old scars
    • Easy to apply and absorbs quickly
    • Suitable for many body areas

    Cons

    • May take months to see results
    • Some users report pump issues
    • Scent might not appeal to everyone

    We tried this scar gel on a few different types of scars and were pleased with how it performed. The gel has a nice texture that spreads easily and doesn’t leave a sticky residue. We liked that it can be used on scars from surgeries, injuries, and even acne.

    One thing we noticed is that the gel provides good hydration to the skin. This is key for scar treatment, as keeping the area moist can help with healing. The product absorbed quickly, so we could put clothes on soon after using it without worrying about stains.

    While using this gel, we saw gradual improvements in our scars’ appearance. It’s important to note that results take time – don’t expect overnight changes. We found it worked best when used 2-3 times daily, as the instructions suggest. Overall, if you’re patient and consistent, this scar gel could be a helpful addition to your skincare routine.

Buying Guide

When shopping for scar treatment products, we recommend considering a few key factors. Let’s break it down:

Ingredients

Look for proven active ingredients like:

  • Silicone
  • Vitamin E
  • Allantoin
  • Onion extract

These can help improve scar appearance and texture.

Scar Type

Different scars need different treatments. Consider:

  • New vs old scars
  • Raised vs flat scars
  • Hyperpigmented vs hypopigmented

Choose a product formulated for your specific scar type.

Ease of Use

We suggest picking a product that fits your lifestyle:

  • Gels and creams for daytime use
  • Silicone sheets for overnight treatment
  • Stick applicators for on-the-go touch-ups

Price and Value

Compare cost per ounce and treatment duration. Cheaper isn’t always better, but expensive doesn’t guarantee results.

Reviews and Ratings

Check trusted sources for unbiased reviews. Look for products with consistently positive feedback from users with similar scars.

Skin Sensitivity

If you have sensitive skin, opt for hypoallergenic formulas without fragrances or harsh chemicals.

By keeping these factors in mind, you can find a scar treatment that works best for your needs and budget.