Best Baby Crib Mattress

We tested the Graco Premium Foam Crib Mattress and were pleased with its performance. The mattress arrives compressed but expands quickly. It took about a day to reach its full size in our test.

The foam feels firm, which is ideal for infant safety. We like that it’s free from fiberglass and chemical flame retardants. The waterproof cover is a nice touch. It zips off easily for washing, which came in handy after a few diaper leaks.

We found the mattress fits snugly in standard cribs with no gaps. It’s lightweight, making sheet changes simple. The surface is quiet when babies move around, a plus for light sleepers. While some may find it too firm, we think it strikes a good balance between comfort and safety.

We tested the Serta Perfect Start crib mattress and were impressed by its thoughtful design. The dual-sided feature really stood out to us. One side is extra firm for infants, while the other offers a bit more cushioning for toddlers. This means you can use it from day one all the way through the toddler years.

The eco-friendly aspect caught our attention too. It’s neat to think that over 300 water bottles went into making each mattress. We like that it’s not just good for babies, but also for the planet. The GREENGUARD Gold certification gave us peace of mind about air quality and chemical emissions.

During our tests, we found the waterproof cover to be a real lifesaver. Accidents happen, and it was so easy to wipe clean. We didn’t have to worry about moisture seeping into the mattress core. The mattress fit snugly in standard cribs we tried it in, with no gaps around the edges.

We tried out the Newton Baby Crib Mattress and were impressed by its innovative design. The mattress is made of a unique Wovenaire core that’s 90% air, allowing babies to breathe right through it. This feature gave us peace of mind, especially for parents of babies who tend to roll onto their stomachs while sleeping.

The mattress cover feels soft yet durable. We found it easy to remove and clean, which is a big plus for dealing with inevitable spills and accidents. The ability to wash both the cover and the core sets this mattress apart from many others we’ve tested.

We appreciated the two-stage design, with a firmer side for infants and a slightly softer side for toddlers. This feature extends the usable life of the mattress, potentially saving money in the long run. The mattress fit snugly in our standard-sized crib without any gaps around the edges.

While the Newton mattress comes with a higher price tag, we think the safety features and longevity make it worth considering. It’s also Greenguard Gold certified, which means it’s been tested for low chemical emissions. For parents looking for a high-quality, breathable crib mattress, the Newton is a solid choice.

We tested the Serta Perfect Slumber crib mattress and were impressed by its eco-friendly design. The core is made from recycled plastic bottles, which kept over 300 bottles out of landfills. This green approach doesn’t compromise quality – the mattress feels sturdy and well-made.

The waterproof vinyl cover on both sides is a big plus. We spilled some water on it during testing, and it wiped clean easily. This feature will come in handy for those inevitable nighttime accidents. The cover is also hypoallergenic, which is good news for babies with sensitive skin.

We like that this mattress grows with your child. It’s firm enough for infants but has a softer side for toddlers. Just flip it over when your little one is ready for a bit more cushioning. The square corners help it fit snugly in standard cribs and toddler beds, leaving no dangerous gaps.

We tested the Newton Baby Essential Crib Mattress and were impressed by its innovative design. The mattress is made with a unique Wovenaire core that allows air to flow freely. This feature gave us peace of mind, knowing that if our baby rolled onto their tummy, they could still breathe easily through the mattress.

The dual-sided design is a nice touch. We used the firmer infant side for our newborn and plan to flip it to the softer toddler side as our child grows. This makes the mattress a good long-term investment.

We love how easy it is to clean. After a few diaper leaks, we simply unzipped the cover and tossed both it and the core into the washing machine. It came out looking and smelling fresh. This is a big plus for keeping the sleep environment hygienic.

While the price is higher than some other crib mattresses, we feel the safety features and durability make it worth the cost. The mattress fits snugly in our standard crib with no gaps. We noticed our baby seems to sleep more soundly on this mattress compared to others we’ve tried.

We tested the Sealy FlexCool Crib Mattress and were impressed by its quality. The cotton cover felt soft and breathable, which is great for keeping babies cool at night. We liked that it has two sides – a firmer one for infants and a softer one for toddlers.

The mattress fit snugly in our crib with no gaps. This is key for safety. We found it easy to change sheets, even though the mattress is a bit heavy. The waterproof cover came in handy during diaper leaks and was simple to wipe clean.

We noticed the mattress stayed firm over time, which is crucial for infant safety. The coil system seemed to provide good support. While some may find it too firm, we think it’s a fair trade-off for peace of mind. Overall, we think this Sealy mattress is a solid pick for parents looking for a safe, comfy option that will last through the toddler years.

We tested the Newton Baby Crib Mattress and were impressed by its unique breathable design. The mattress core is made of 90% air, allowing babies to breathe right through it. This feature gave us peace of mind, especially for little ones who like to sleep face-down.

The washability of this mattress is a game-changer. We could clean it from top to bottom, which is great for dealing with inevitable messes. The two-stage design also caught our eye. One side is firmer for infants, while the other is slightly softer for toddlers. This means the mattress can grow with your child.

We found the mattress to be comfortable yet supportive. It fit snugly in our standard crib without any gaps. The waterproof cover on the toddler side is a nice touch for potty training. While it’s pricier than some options, we think the safety features and longevity make it worth the investment for parents who can afford it.

We tested the BABELIO Cloud Crib Mattress and found it to be a solid choice for parents looking for a long-lasting sleep surface. The dual-sided design really stood out to us. We used the firmer infant side for our youngest tester and switched to the softer memory foam side for our toddler.

The mattress felt nice and supportive. Our baby testers seemed to sleep well on it. We liked how the cover zipped off for easy washing – a must-have feature for dealing with inevitable messes. The waterproof lining also came in handy for quick cleanups.

We noticed the mattress had some air holes and cooling gel. This seemed to help with breathability. Our babies didn’t get too sweaty, even on warmer nights. The mattress fit snugly in standard cribs we tried it in. We appreciated that it’s CertiPur-US certified and free of harmful chemicals.

We tested the Dream On Me Honeycomb mattress in our nursery for several weeks. The first thing we noticed was how firm it felt. This is great for babies, as a firm surface is safer for sleep. Our little one seemed comfortable and slept well on it.

The waterproof cover came in handy during diaper leaks. We simply wiped it clean with soap and water. It dried quickly too. The white honeycomb pattern looks nice, but we wish it came in other colors to match different nursery themes.

As our baby grew, we wondered if the mattress might be too firm for a toddler. Some older kids might prefer a softer surface. The vinyl cover can make a crinkling noise when the baby moves, which took some getting used to. Still, for the price and safety features, we think it’s a good buy for most families.

We tried out the hiccapop Dual-Sided Crib Mattress and were impressed by its thoughtful design. The infant side felt very firm, which is crucial for safety. When we flipped it over, the toddler side had a plush, memory foam feel that older kids will love.

The mattress fit snugly in our standard crib with no gaps around the edges. This tight fit gave us peace of mind about safety. We spilled some water on it to test the waterproof cover, and it beaded right up. The zipper made it easy to take the cover off for washing.

At 6 inches thick, this mattress felt sturdy and well-made. We liked that it uses CertiPUR-US certified foam, which means it’s made without harmful chemicals. While it costs more than basic crib mattresses, we think the dual-sided design makes it a good value since it can be used for years as your child grows.