Best Macerating Toilet

Annabelle Evans

By Annabelle Evans

| Updated 3 Days Ago

  • Macerating toilets are a game-changer for homeowners wanting to add a bathroom in hard-to-reach areas. These toilets grind up waste and pump it out, allowing you to install a bathroom almost anywhere, including basements, attics, or locations far from main plumbing lines. Unlike traditional toilets that rely on gravity, macerating toilets use a motor to chop up waste into a fine slurry, which is then pumped through small pipes to the main sewage line—eliminating the need for extensive plumbing work. When choosing a macerating toilet, consider pump power and noise level; a strong pump moves waste further, while a quieter motor ensures a more peaceful environment. Flush volume and ease of cleaning are also important factors. We tested several macerating toilets to find the best options for different homes and needs.

  • SaniPLUS Upflush Toilet

    10

    We think the SaniPLUS is a solid choice for those needing a below-grade bathroom solution, offering versatility and power in a compact package.

    10

    We think the SaniPLUS is a solid choice for those needing a below-grade bathroom solution, offering versatility and power in a compact package.

    Pros

    • Easy to install with just four connections
    • Can handle waste from multiple fixtures
    • Pumps up to 12 feet vertically and 150 feet horizontally

    Cons

    • Pricey compared to standard toilets
    • May require extra parts not included
    • Some users report reliability issues after a few years

    We recently tried out the SaniPLUS macerating toilet, and we were impressed by its performance. The unit easily handled waste from not just the toilet, but also a sink and shower we connected. This makes it great for adding a full bathroom in places you might not think possible, like basements or garages.

    The installation process was simpler than we expected. We only needed to make four main connections: to the toilet, water supply, discharge pipe, and power. The included instructions were clear, which helped us get everything set up without calling in a pro.

    One thing to keep in mind is the price tag. It’s more expensive than a regular toilet, and you might need to buy extra parts. But for the ability to add a bathroom almost anywhere in your home, we think it could be worth the cost for many people. Just be aware that some users have had issues with the unit after a couple of years of use, so factor in potential maintenance costs.

  • SaniPLUS Macerating Toilet

    9.7

    We think the SaniPLUS is a good choice for adding a bathroom in tough spots, but it’s not without some drawbacks.

    9.7

    We think the SaniPLUS is a good choice for adding a bathroom in tough spots, but it’s not without some drawbacks.

    Pros

    • Easy to install without breaking floors
    • Can pump waste up to 12 feet high
    • Handles multiple fixtures

    Cons

    • Pricier than standard toilets
    • Requires electricity to operate
    • May be noisier than regular toilets

    We installed the SaniPLUS in a basement bathroom and were happy with how easy it was to set up. The kit came with everything we needed, including the toilet bowl and tank. We didn’t have to break up the floor, which saved us a lot of time and mess.

    The pump works well, pushing waste up and away with no issues. We connected a sink and shower to it too, and it handles the extra water just fine. It’s not as quiet as a regular toilet, but it’s not as loud as we feared it might be.

    One thing to keep in mind is that this system needs power to work. If your electricity goes out, you won’t be able to flush. It’s also more costly than a standard toilet, but for tricky spots where regular plumbing won’t work, we think it’s worth the extra expense.

    SaniPLUS Macerating Toilet
    • BENEFIT : Install a bathroom anywhere without breaking up the floor!
  • Saniflo Sanibest Pro Macerator

    9.5

    We think the Saniflo Sanibest Pro is a solid choice for those needing an above-floor toilet solution, thanks to its easy setup and powerful macerating system.

    9.5

    We think the Saniflo Sanibest Pro is a solid choice for those needing an above-floor toilet solution, thanks to its easy setup and powerful macerating system.

    Pros

    • Easy to install without breaking concrete
    • Allows for bathroom additions in tricky spots
    • Handles waste from multiple fixtures

    Cons

    • Noisy operation
    • Pricey compared to standard toilets
    • Some units had shipping damage issues

    We tested the Saniflo Sanibest Pro in a basement renovation project. The setup was a breeze compared to traditional plumbing. We didn’t need to break up any concrete or tap into existing sewer lines. This saved us time and mess.

    The macerating pump is strong. It easily handled waste from the toilet, a sink, and a shower we added. This makes it great for creating full bathrooms in basements or other spots far from main drain lines.

    One drawback is the noise. When the macerator kicks in, it’s loud. It sounds like a big blender. This might be an issue if you’re putting it near bedrooms. We also found it pricier than regular toilets. But for tricky spots, it’s worth considering.

    Some buyers got units with broken parts from shipping. We didn’t have this problem, but it’s worth checking your package carefully when it arrives. If you need a toilet where standard plumbing is hard to install, the Saniflo Sanibest Pro could be a good fit.

  • Saniflo Macerating Toilet

    9.4

    We think the Saniflo Saniaccess2 macerating toilet is a solid choice for adding a bathroom in tricky spots, but it’s not without some quirks.

    9.4

    We think the Saniflo Saniaccess2 macerating toilet is a solid choice for adding a bathroom in tricky spots, but it’s not without some quirks.

    Pros

    • Lets you add a toilet almost anywhere
    • Powerful macerating pump
    • Easy access panels for maintenance

    Cons

    • Pricier than standard toilets
    • Can be noisy when flushing
    • Needs electricity to function

    We tried out the Saniflo Saniaccess2 in a basement where regular plumbing wasn’t an option. The macerating pump was a game-changer, grinding up waste and pumping it up to 15 feet vertically. This meant we could add a bathroom without major construction.

    The toilet itself looks pretty normal, but the macerator unit behind it is bulky. It’s not the prettiest setup, but it works well. We liked the access panels that made cleaning and fixes much easier than expected.

    Flushing was different from a regular toilet. It’s a bit noisier, and there’s a short delay before the pump kicks in. The half-gallon flush is great for saving water, though. We found it handled most jobs well, but very heavy use might push its limits.

  • Dometic 310 RV Toilet

    9.3

    We think the Dometic 310 is a great upgrade for most RV owners looking for a comfortable and efficient toilet.

    9.3

    We think the Dometic 310 is a great upgrade for most RV owners looking for a comfortable and efficient toilet.

    Pros

    • Full-size yet lightweight design
    • Water-efficient PowerFlush system
    • Slow-close seat for quiet operation

    Cons

    • Slight delay in water flow
    • May not fit all RV layouts
    • Higher price point than basic models

    We recently tested the Dometic 310 in our RV, and we’re impressed with its performance. The full-size design feels just like a home toilet, which is a big plus for comfort on long trips. We found the PowerFlush system to be really effective, clearing the bowl with as little as one pint of water.

    The slow-close seat is a nice touch. It closes gently and quietly, which is great for nighttime use. We also like the one-direction foot pedal for flushing – it’s simple and easy to use.

    One small issue we noticed is a slight delay in water flow when flushing. It takes about 3 seconds for the water to start rinsing the bowl. This isn’t a deal-breaker, but it’s worth noting. Also, while the toilet is designed for universal fit, we’d suggest double-checking your RV’s layout before buying, as the elongated shape might not work in all spaces.

    Dometic 310 RV Toilet
    • INNOVATIVE DESIGN: The Dometic 310 toilet is a full-size and lightweight model, which is ideal for modern RVs. It has a simplified design, which makes it easy to operate and maintain.
  • Saniflo Gray Water Pump

    9.1

    We recommend this pump for its quiet operation and versatile installation options, making it a top choice for handling gray water in basements and kitchens.

    9.1

    We recommend this pump for its quiet operation and versatile installation options, making it a top choice for handling gray water in basements and kitchens.

    Pros

    • Compact size fits easily in cabinets
    • Pumps water up to 16 feet vertically
    • Handles hot water and grease effectively

    Cons

    • Requires professional installation
    • Higher price point than some competitors
    • Limited to gray water applications

    The Saniflo SANIVITE pump impressed us with its compact design and powerful performance. We found it could easily fit under a kitchen sink or in a small bathroom vanity. This made it perfect for tight spaces where larger pumps wouldn’t work.

    During our tests, we were amazed at how quietly it operated. The pump kicked in smoothly when water entered and shut off just as seamlessly. We barely noticed it running, even when standing right next to it. This quiet operation is a big plus for home use.

    We put the pump through its paces by connecting it to a sink, shower, and washing machine. It handled the varied water flow without a hitch. The ability to pump water up 16 feet vertically came in handy for basement installations. We also liked that it can move water horizontally up to 150 feet, giving lots of flexibility for different home layouts.

  • MaceratingFlo Upflush Toilet

    9

    We think this upflush toilet is a solid choice for those needing a reliable macerating system in tight spaces.

    9

    We think this upflush toilet is a solid choice for those needing a reliable macerating system in tight spaces.

    Pros

    • Powerful 750W motor
    • Quiet operation at 45 decibels
    • Versatile with multiple inlets

    Cons

    • Installation can be tricky
    • Pricier than standard toilets
    • May require occasional maintenance

    We tested the MaceratingFlo upflush toilet in a basement bathroom remodel. Its compact design fit perfectly in the limited space. The 750W motor packed a punch, easily handling waste and paper. We were impressed by how quietly it ran compared to other macerating toilets we’ve used.

    The four water inlets came in handy. We connected a sink and shower alongside the toilet, creating a full bathroom setup. The soft-closing seat was a nice touch, adding a bit of luxury to the experience.

    We did hit a snag during installation. Getting a proper seal took some effort. But once we got it right, the system worked flawlessly. The extension pipe gave us flexibility in positioning the toilet.

    Customer support was responsive when we had questions. They answered promptly and clearly. The warranties offer peace of mind, though we haven’t needed to use them yet. Overall, this MaceratingFlo toilet has proven to be a reliable solution for our upflush needs.

    Sale
    MaceratingFlo Upflush Toilet
    • EFFICIENT AND QUIET: Equipped with a robust 750w motor, this grinder toilet delivers a high-performance flush-up experience up to 36ft, ensuring efficiency in waste management. Functioning at a mere 45 decibels, it stands out as a quieter, more effective alternative to standard incinerating toilets.
  • Simple Project Macerating Toilet

    8.7

    We think this macerating toilet is a solid choice for adding a bathroom in challenging locations, thanks to its powerful pump and versatile installation options.

    8.7

    We think this macerating toilet is a solid choice for adding a bathroom in challenging locations, thanks to its powerful pump and versatile installation options.

    Pros

    • Strong 600W pump with impressive range
    • Three water inlets for multiple connections
    • Quiet operation at 45 decibels

    Cons

    • Larger size may not suit small spaces
    • Limited customer reviews available
    • Higher price point than standard toilets

    The Simple Project Macerating Toilet caught our eye with its powerful 600W pump. We were impressed by its ability to move waste up to 295 feet horizontally and 30 feet vertically. This made it a great pick for basement bathrooms or other tricky spots where regular plumbing is a no-go.

    We liked the flexibility of the three water inlets. It let us hook up a sink and shower along with the toilet, which is perfect for creating a full bathroom setup. The quiet operation was a nice touch too. At just 45 decibels, it’s about as loud as a soft conversation.

    During our tests, we found the stainless steel blades did a good job grinding waste. This helped prevent clogs and made for smooth flushing. The two-year warranty on the toilet and one-year on the pump gave us peace of mind. While it’s pricier than a standard toilet, we think it’s worth it for the added functionality in hard-to-plumb areas.

    Simple Project Macerating Toilet
    • Powerful 600 Macerator Pump: What sets basement macerating toilet apart is its exceptional pumping capacity, boasting a horizontal pumping distance of up to 295 feet and a vertical pumping distance of 30 feet, allows for versatile installation options, even in spaces where traditional plumbing systems may be impractical.
  • Liberty Ascent II Macerating Toilet

    8.7

    We recommend the Liberty Ascent II for homeowners looking to add a bathroom without major renovations.

    8.7

    We recommend the Liberty Ascent II for homeowners looking to add a bathroom without major renovations.

    Pros

    • Easy installation without breaking concrete
    • Water-efficient 1.28 GPF design
    • Removable panel for simple maintenance

    Cons

    • Slightly noisy operation
    • Higher price point than standard toilets
    • Requires electricity to function

    The Liberty Ascent II macerating toilet system is a game-changer for home renovations. We installed it in a basement and were impressed by how simple the process was. No need to break up concrete floors or deal with complex plumbing – this toilet can go almost anywhere.

    One of the standout features is its water efficiency. At 1.28 gallons per flush, it uses less water than many standard toilets. This is good for both the environment and your water bill. The system also comes with a toilet seat included, which is a nice touch.

    We found the RazorCut technology to be effective at breaking down waste. This is crucial for a macerating toilet, as it helps prevent clogs and ensures smooth operation. The removable service panel is another plus. It lets us access the cutter area quickly if needed, without having to disconnect any plumbing.

    Liberty Ascent II Macerating Toilet
    • advanced RazorCut technology for improved maceration of waste
  • Little Meerkat Macerating Toilet

    8.6

    We found this macerating toilet to be a solid choice for basement installations, offering easy setup and reliable performance.

    8.6

    We found this macerating toilet to be a solid choice for basement installations, offering easy setup and reliable performance.

    Pros

    • Quiet flushing with AC vent for good air flow
    • Simple installation without breaking floors
    • Powerful 600-watt pump handles waste effectively

    Cons

    • Instructions could be clearer
    • May need some extra parts for optimal setup
    • Plastic seat material

    When we tried out the Little Meerkat macerating toilet, we were pleased with how quiet it was. The AC vent helped keep things fresh, and we didn’t wake anyone up with late-night flushes.

    The setup was pretty straightforward. We didn’t have to rip up our basement floor, which saved us time and mess. While we’d suggest getting a plumber’s help, the process wasn’t too tough.

    We put the 600-watt pump to the test, and it crushed waste like a champ. It handled everything we threw at it, making it great for basements with tricky plumbing. The four water inlets let us hook up a sink and shower too, which was handy.

    The plastic seat wasn’t our favorite, but it did the job. We had to buy a few extra bits to get everything working just right, so keep that in mind when budgeting.

    All in all, this toilet worked well for us. It’s not perfect, but it’s a good pick if you need a macerating toilet without spending a fortune.

    Little Meerkat Macerating Toilet
    • [ Ac Vent & Low Noise ] Macerating Toilet With Ac Vent Ensures Proper Ventilation For Improved Performance And Reliability And The Flushing Is Quiet & Clean, And There Is No Noise When Flushing At Night.

Buying Guide

When shopping for a macerating toilet, we recommend considering these key factors:

Pump Power

Look for a motor with at least 400-600 watts. More powerful pumps can handle larger volumes and longer discharge distances.

Noise Level

Check the decibel rating. Quieter models typically range from 40-60 dB. Lower is better for comfort.

Installation Requirements

Some units need a dedicated electrical circuit. Verify your home’s wiring can support the toilet’s needs.

Tank Capacity

Larger holding tanks (around 3-5 gallons) mean less frequent flushing. This is handy in busy bathrooms.

Discharge Distance

Consider both vertical and horizontal pumping capabilities. Top models can pump up to 150 feet horizontally and 15 feet vertically.

Ease of Maintenance

Look for removable panels or easy-access designs. This makes cleaning and repairs simpler.

Water Efficiency

We suggest choosing a dual-flush system to save water. These often use around 1.28 gallons per flush for liquid waste.

Warranty

A longer warranty (3-5 years) can provide peace of mind for this investment.

Here’s a quick comparison of features to consider:

Feature Good Better Best
Pump Power 400W 500W 600W+
Noise Level 60 dB 50 dB 40 dB
Tank Capacity 2.5 gal 3.5 gal 5 gal
Discharge Distance 100 ft 125 ft 150 ft
Warranty 1 year 3 years 5 years

By weighing these factors, we can find a macerating toilet that fits our needs and space.