Best Squirrel Poison

Annabelle Evans

By Annabelle Evans

| Updated 3 Days Ago

  • Squirrels may be cute, but they can cause significant damage to gardens, attics, and homes. When other methods fail, some turn to squirrel poison as a last resort. This rodenticide comes in various forms, like pellets, blocks, or liquid baits, designed to eliminate squirrels quickly. However, using poison is a serious decision that requires careful consideration of risks to pets, children, and other wildlife, along with checking local laws, as many places regulate rodent poison use. Humane alternatives are also available. If you’re considering squirrel poison, focus on active ingredients, application methods, and safety features. We researched different options to find those that effectively balance safety and results.

  • Kaput Ground Squirrel Bait

    10

    We found this bait to be a slow but effective option for controlling ground squirrels, though it requires patience and consistent use.

    10

    We found this bait to be a slow but effective option for controlling ground squirrels, though it requires patience and consistent use.

    Pros

    • Kills both squirrels and fleas
    • EPA-approved formula
    • Large 5-pound container

    Cons

    • Takes time to see results
    • Needs regular replenishing
    • May not work for all squirrel species

    We tried Kaput Ground Squirrel Bait on our property after noticing an increase in squirrel activity. The granules were easy to spread in areas where we saw the most burrows. We liked that it targets both squirrels and fleas, addressing two pest problems at once.

    It’s important to note that this bait doesn’t work overnight. We had to keep applying it for several weeks before we noticed a decrease in squirrel sightings. The slow-acting nature of the bait means squirrels don’t associate it with danger, so they keep eating it.

    One downside we found was the need to constantly refill bait stations. Squirrels seemed to enjoy the taste, which is good for effectiveness but means going through the product quickly. While it worked well for our California ground squirrels, some users report mixed results with other species.

    Kaput Ground Squirrel Bait
    • The ONLY bait that kills ground squirrels and their fleas!
  • Kaput Squirrel Eliminator

    9.7

    We recommend this product for its effectiveness in controlling ground squirrel populations on larger properties.

    9.7

    We recommend this product for its effectiveness in controlling ground squirrel populations on larger properties.

    Pros

    • Kills both squirrels and their fleas
    • Large 25-pound bucket for extensive use
    • Easy to apply in burrows

    Cons

    • May take time to see results
    • Not suitable for areas with pets or children
    • Requires frequent reapplication

    We tested Kaput Ground Squirrel Bait on a 6-acre property overrun with ground squirrels. The 25-pound bucket gave us plenty of bait to work with, allowing us to treat multiple burrows over an extended period.

    Applying the bait was straightforward. We placed it directly into the squirrel holes and replenished it as needed. It’s important to note that patience is key – we didn’t see immediate results, but over time, we noticed a significant decrease in squirrel activity.

    One feature we appreciated was its ability to target both squirrels and their fleas. This dual-action approach helps prevent potential disease spread. However, we must caution that this product isn’t suitable for areas where pets or children play, as it could pose risks if ingested.

    Sale
    Kaput Squirrel Eliminator
    • The ONLY bait that kills ground squirrels and their fleas!
  • Tomcat Bait Chunx

    9.5

    We recommend Tomcat Bait Chunx for effective rat and mouse control in agricultural settings and for professional use.

    9.5

    We recommend Tomcat Bait Chunx for effective rat and mouse control in agricultural settings and for professional use.

    Pros

    • Kills up to 12 mice per block
    • Works on resistant rodents
    • Stops pests from feeding quickly

    Cons

    • Not for home use
    • Requires bait stations
    • May be harmful if misused

    We tested Tomcat Bait Chunx in several settings with serious rodent problems. The chunky bait blocks were easy to place in tamper-resistant stations. We noticed fewer signs of rats and mice within days of setting out the bait.

    The active ingredient, bromethalin, worked fast to stop rodents from eating more food. This helps control large populations quickly. We found it especially useful for Norway rats, roof rats, and house mice that had become resistant to other poisons.

    One downside is that Tomcat Bait Chunx is only for agricultural use or by professional pest control experts. It must be used within 100 feet of buildings. The bait also requires proper stations to keep it away from kids, pets, and other animals. While very effective, it needs careful handling to use safely.

    Sale
    Tomcat Bait Chunx
    • Tomcat with Bromethalin Bait Chunx are for agricultural use and professional applicators, and must be used within 100 ft. of man-made structures
  • JT Eaton Peanut Butter Bait Blocks

    9.4

    We think these bait blocks are a solid choice for tackling serious rodent problems in homes and outdoor areas.

    9.4

    We think these bait blocks are a solid choice for tackling serious rodent problems in homes and outdoor areas.

    Pros

    • Large 9 lb bucket contains 144 blocks
    • Peanut butter flavor attracts mice and rats
    • Can be used indoors and outdoors

    Cons

    • Takes several days to be effective
    • May cause rodents to die in hard-to-reach spots
    • Requires careful handling and placement

    We tested these JT Eaton bait blocks in an area with a persistent mouse problem. The peanut butter scent seemed to draw them in quickly. Within a week, we noticed a big drop in rodent activity around the house.

    The bucket comes packed with 144 one-ounce blocks. That’s enough to treat a large area or last through multiple applications. We liked that we could easily refill bait stations as needed.

    One thing to keep in mind is that it’s not an instant fix. The anticoagulant effect takes a few days to work. We also had to be careful about placement to keep pets and kids safe. But for stubborn infestations, these bait blocks got the job done when other methods failed.

    JT Eaton Peanut Butter Bait Blocks
    • RODENT CONTROL: Anticoagulant block bait that eliminates rats and mice within a few days
  • Ramik Ground Squirrel Bait

    9.3

    We found this bait to be a mixed bag for controlling California ground squirrels near buildings.

    9.3

    We found this bait to be a mixed bag for controlling California ground squirrels near buildings.

    Pros

    • Fish-flavored pellets attract squirrels
    • Weather-resistant formula
    • Easy to use in bait stations

    Cons

    • Only works on California ground squirrels
    • Must be used within 100 feet of structures
    • Takes time to see results

    When we tested Neogen’s Ramik Ground Squirrel Bait, we noticed its fish scent right away. The pellets smelled strong, which seemed good for luring squirrels. We placed them in secure bait stations around our test property.

    The weather-resistant pellets held up well outdoors. Rain and sun didn’t seem to affect them much. This meant we didn’t have to replace the bait as often as some other brands we’ve tried.

    We saw fewer squirrels after about a week of use. But it wasn’t a quick fix. The anticoagulant takes time to work. We also had to be careful about where we put the bait stations. The 100-foot rule limited our options on larger properties.

    Ramik Ground Squirrel Bait
    • RODENT CONTROL: Helps stop damage caused by California Ground Squirrels
  • JT Eaton Peanut Butter Bait Blocks

    9.1

    We recommend these bait blocks for effective rodent control, especially for larger infestations.

    9.1

    We recommend these bait blocks for effective rodent control, especially for larger infestations.

    Pros

    • Tasty peanut butter flavor attracts rodents
    • Works on both rats and mice
    • Resealable pail for easy storage

    Cons

    • Takes a few days to eliminate pests
    • Not safe for use around pets or children
    • May require multiple applications

    These peanut butter-flavored bait blocks from JT Eaton pack a punch against rodent problems. We tested them in a variety of settings and found they worked well to attract and eliminate both rats and mice. The peanut butter scent seems irresistible to rodents, drawing them in quickly.

    We like that the blocks come in a resealable pail, making it easy to store and use as needed. Each block has a hole in the center, which is handy for securing them in bait stations. This helps keep the poison away from pets and kids.

    One downside is that it can take a few days to see results. We had to be patient and keep replacing eaten blocks. For bigger infestations, you may need to use quite a few blocks over time. Still, we found these bait blocks to be a cost-effective option compared to hiring an exterminator for ongoing rodent issues.

    Sale
    JT Eaton Peanut Butter Bait Blocks
    • RODENT CONTROL: Anticoagulant block bait that eliminates rat and mice within a few days
  • eXuby Squirrel Trap

    9

    We don’t recommend this trap due to mixed results and potential safety concerns.

    9

    We don’t recommend this trap due to mixed results and potential safety concerns.

    Pros

    • Easy to set up
    • Reusable design
    • No chemicals used

    Cons

    • Inconsistent performance
    • May not kill instantly
    • Potential safety risk

    We tested the eXuby Squirrel Trap in various settings. Its simple setup was a plus – just press to arm and you’re ready. The trap is also washable and reusable, which we liked.

    But we had issues with its effectiveness. Some squirrels triggered the trap without getting caught. When it did work, the results weren’t always quick or humane. This raised concerns about animal welfare.

    Safety is another worry. The strong spring could harm pets or kids if not used carefully. While it’s chemical-free, which is good, the overall design needs work. For now, we think there are better options for humane pest control.

    eXuby Squirrel Trap
    • Instant & Humane: Equipped with an ultra-strong spring, our squirrel trap delivers a swift and humane end. No suffering, no mess, no fuss! Just quick and compassionate pest control.
  • USKICH Squirrel Repellent Balls

    8.7

    We found these repellent balls to be a mixed bag for keeping squirrels away.

    8.7

    We found these repellent balls to be a mixed bag for keeping squirrels away.

    Pros

    • Easy to place around your yard
    • Made with natural essential oils
    • Comes with gloves and hanging bags

    Cons

    • Effectiveness decreases after rain
    • Strong smell may bother some people
    • Mixed results in repelling squirrels

    We tried out these USKICH repellent balls in our garden to see if they could keep pesky squirrels at bay. The balls were simple to set up – we just placed them near our plants and in areas where squirrels like to hang out. They come in a pack of 20, which was enough to cover a decent-sized area.

    The balls are made with essential oils, mainly garlic oil. This gives them a very strong smell that’s meant to drive squirrels away. We noticed the scent right away, and it was pretty intense. Some of us found it a bit much, so keep that in mind if you’re sensitive to smells.

    We saw fewer squirrels in the first few days after putting the balls out. But then it rained, and they seemed less effective afterward. We had to replace some of them, which was a bit of a hassle. The package includes gloves and hanging bags, which were handy for setting up the balls without getting the smell on our hands.

    USKICH Squirrel Repellent Balls
    • Long Lasting Effective - Our squirrel repellent is made of concentrated and sustainable essential oils,, mainly ultra powerful garlic oil,emits multiple strong scent, causes strong irritation to squirrels,making them panic to naturally avoid your garden. Please replace the product after rain. Rain will have an impact on product performance.You can place a few more in the squirrel activity area. Specifically designed to repel squirrels outdoors
  • Mighty Mint Rodent Repeller

    8.7

    We think this peppermint oil spray is a good choice for those seeking a natural way to deter rodents.

    8.7

    We think this peppermint oil spray is a good choice for those seeking a natural way to deter rodents.

    Pros

    • Pleasant minty scent
    • Safe for people and pets
    • Highly concentrated formula

    Cons

    • May need frequent reapplication
    • Not 100% effective for all rodents
    • Large 1-gallon size may be too much for some

    We tried out the Mighty Mint Rodent Repeller in our own homes and garages. The strong peppermint smell was nice and refreshing. It wasn’t overpowering like some chemical sprays.

    We sprayed it in areas where we’d seen mouse activity. The concentrated formula seemed to work well. We noticed fewer signs of rodents after a few days of use. But we did have to reapply it every week or so to keep the scent strong.

    This natural spray felt safer to use around our families and pets compared to poison. The big 1-gallon jug lasted a long time. We liked using it in our cars and RVs too. While not perfect, we think it’s a good option to try before harsher methods.

    Mighty Mint Rodent Repeller
    • Naturally Safe for People and Pets When Used as Directed - Smells Good Too!
  • Wilco Ground Squirrel Bait Station

    8.6

    We recommend this bait station for its effective and safe design in managing ground squirrel populations.

    8.6

    We recommend this bait station for its effective and safe design in managing ground squirrel populations.

    Pros

    • Durable green plastic construction
    • Child-resistant lid for safety
    • Keeps bait fresh and protected

    Cons

    • May be pricey for multiple stations
    • Lid can be tough to open
    • Requires separate bait purchase

    We tested the Wilco Ground Squirrel Bait Station in areas with high rodent activity. Its sturdy build impressed us, standing up to outdoor conditions without cracking or fading. The 3-inch size is just right for ground squirrels, and we found it easy to place near burrows.

    The child-resistant lid gave us peace of mind. It kept out curious pets and other animals, focusing the bait on our target pests. We liked how it also kept the bait dry and fresh, even during light rain.

    For big yards, you might need a few stations. We set them 30-40 feet apart as suggested. While effective, buying multiple can add up. The lid’s safety feature, while crucial, took some getting used to. We got the hang of it after a few tries. Remember, you’ll need to buy bait separately – this is just the station.

    Sale
    Wilco Ground Squirrel Bait Station
    • Wilco Ground Squirrel Bait Station This Durable High Grade Green Plastic Bait Station Is Used With Ground Squirrel Bait Where There Would Be Ground Squirrel Activity

Buying Guide

When looking for squirrel poison, there are a few key things to keep in mind. We’ve researched the options and compiled this guide to help you choose.

Active Ingredients

Look for products containing anticoagulants like bromadiolone or diphacinone. These are effective and work within a few days.

Bait Form

Poison comes in several forms:

  • Pellets
  • Blocks
  • Liquid concentrates

Pellets and blocks are easiest to use. Concentrates require mixing.

Safety Features

Pick baits with tamper-resistant stations to keep pets and kids safe. Bright colors help you spot spills.

Amount Needed

Calculate how much you’ll need based on the size of your yard. Most products list coverage on the label.

Weather Resistance

If using outdoors, choose weather-resistant baits that won’t dissolve in rain.

Ease of Use

Pre-baited stations are simplest. But refillable ones cost less long-term.

Attractants

Some baits contain flavors squirrels like. This can make them more effective.

By weighing these factors, you can find the right squirrel poison for your needs. Always follow the label instructions carefully.