Best Toaster

We tried out the Mueller UltraToast in our kitchen and were impressed by its clean stainless steel look. It fits nicely against our backsplash without taking up too much counter space. The touch buttons and LED display make it simple to adjust settings.

When we popped in some thick artisan bread slices, they fit easily in the wide slots. We like how the self-centering guides ensure even toasting. The six browning levels let us dial in our preferred crispness, though we noticed it takes a bit longer than some other toasters we’ve used.

The defrost and reheat functions came in handy for frozen waffles and leftover toast. Clean-up is a breeze thanks to the removable crumb tray. While it feels a bit light for its size, we think the Mueller UltraToast offers good value for families wanting a versatile 4-slice toaster with helpful features.

We’ve been using this GE toaster in our test kitchen, and it’s quickly become a favorite. The wide slots easily fit bagels and thick slices of artisan bread. We love how we can adjust the settings to get our toast just right, from lightly golden to dark and crispy.

The illuminated buttons are a nice touch. They clearly show which setting we’ve chosen, even in low light. We found the cancel button handy when we needed to stop toasting mid-cycle.

Cleaning is a breeze thanks to the removable crumb tray. We simply pull it out and empty it over the trash. The stainless steel exterior looks sleek on our countertop and wipes clean easily.

We did notice that sometimes one side of the bread toasts a bit darker than the other. It’s not a deal-breaker, but worth mentioning. Also, if you have a big family, you might want a 4-slice model instead.

We’ve been using this BUYDEEM toaster for a while now, and it’s quickly become our go-to for morning breakfasts. The wide slots easily fit thick slices of artisan bread and bagels, which is a huge plus. We no longer struggle to fish out smaller items thanks to the high lift lever.

The bagel function is a standout feature. It toasts the cut side while gently warming the outside, giving us perfectly crispy bagels every time. We also appreciate the 7 shade settings, which let us get our toast just right, whether we want it lightly golden or well-done.

Cleaning is a breeze with the pull-out crumb tray. We just slide it out, empty it into the trash, and slide it back in. The retro design adds a fun pop of color to our kitchen, though the greenish hue might not be everyone’s cup of tea. Overall, we find this toaster to be a reliable and attractive addition to our countertop.

The Wolf Gourmet toaster impressed us with its thoughtful design and consistent results. Its extra-wide slots easily fit bagels and artisan breads without squishing. The self-centering guides worked great, keeping even thin slices perfectly centered for even browning on both sides.

We loved the precise shade control. The dial let us dial in our ideal toast color, from barely golden to dark and crispy. The bagel and frozen settings also came in handy. The extended bread lifter was a nice touch, making it easy to grab smaller items.

This toaster feels built to last. The stainless steel body and commercial-grade heating elements should stand up to years of use. While pricey, we think it’s a worthwhile investment for toast enthusiasts. Just be aware it takes up a fair amount of counter space.

The Geek Chef 4-Slice Toaster impressed us with its sleek stainless steel design and practical features. We found the 1.5-inch wide slots perfect for toasting everything from regular bread to chunky bagels. It’s a relief not to struggle with fitting our favorite artisanal loaves anymore.

We love the dual independent control panels. They let us toast different items at the same time, which is super handy for families with varied tastes. The six browning settings gave us plenty of options to get our toast just right, from lightly golden to dark and crunchy.

The bagel, defrost, and cancel functions worked well in our tests. We especially liked the high lift lever, which made grabbing smaller slices much easier. Cleaning is a breeze thanks to the removable crumb tray. While it’s mostly great, we noticed the exterior gets quite hot, so be careful. Some items like English muffins needed extra time to toast evenly.

We tested the SEEDEEM 4-Slice Digital Toaster in our kitchen for a week, and it quickly became a morning favorite. The stainless steel body looks sleek on the counter, and the wide slots easily fit our bagels and thick-cut bread.

The LCD display is a standout feature. We loved watching the countdown timer, which took the guesswork out of toasting. No more burnt toast surprises! The six shade settings let us dial in our perfect golden-brown every time.

One of the best things about this toaster is the dual control area. We could toast a bagel on one side and regular bread on the other, each with its own settings. It’s great for families with different tastes. The defrost and reheat functions also came in handy for frozen waffles and leftover slices.

We’ve been using this SEEDEEM toaster for a while now, and it’s become a morning favorite. The colorful LCD screens are a nice touch. They show the shade setting and countdown time, so we always know when our toast will pop up. No more burnt surprises!

The toaster has 7 shade settings. We found the middle settings work best for most breads. There’s even a special setting that gives a nice burnt flavor without drying out the bread. It’s perfect for those who like their toast with a bit of crunch.

We love the dual control areas. It’s great for families with different tastes. We can make light toast on one side and dark on the other at the same time. The wide slots fit bagels and thick slices easily. The lift lever is smooth, and the auto pop-up works well. Clean-up is simple with the removable crumb tray. It’s a solid choice for busy kitchens.

We recently tried out the SEEDEEM Retro Red Toaster and were impressed by its performance. The LCD display is a standout feature, clearly showing the remaining toasting time. This took the guesswork out of getting our bread just right.

The 7 shade settings gave us plenty of control over our toast. We found the middle settings worked well for most bread types, while the higher settings were perfect for bagels. The extra wide slots easily fit thick slices and bagels without squishing them.

We appreciated the 4-in-1 functions, especially the defrost option for frozen bread. The reheat function was handy for warming up toast that had gone cold. The removable crumb tray made cleanup a breeze, though we wish the toaster felt a bit sturdier overall.

We’ve been using the Cuisinart Compact Toaster in our test kitchen for a few weeks now. Its small footprint is perfect for tight spaces, and we like how it can be placed sideways or forward-facing to fit different counter layouts.

The wide slots easily accommodate bagels and thick-cut bread. We found the high-lift lever helpful for fishing out smaller items without burning our fingers. The 7 shade settings give good control over toasting, though we noticed some slight unevenness on occasion.

We appreciate the handy defrost and cancel buttons. The slide-out crumb tray makes cleanup simple. While the plastic body may not feel as solid as pricier metal models, it keeps the toaster lightweight and easy to move. For the price, we think this Cuisinart offers good value and performance for everyday toasting needs.

We put this BLACK+DECKER toaster through its paces in our kitchen. The extra-wide slots easily handled everything from thin sandwich bread to thick artisan loaves. We liked being able to choose from six different shade settings to get our toast just right.

The frozen and bagel buttons came in handy. When we popped in frozen waffles, the toaster adjusted automatically for perfect results. The bagel function toasted the cut side while just warming the outside.

We found the slide-out crumb tray simple to use and clean. It kept our counter free of mess. The black plastic exterior looks sleek, though some may prefer a metal finish. At 850 watts, it toasted quickly and efficiently.

While mostly even, we noticed the edges of bread were occasionally a bit lighter than the center. The cord comes out of the front, which took some getting used to. But these were minor quibbles for an otherwise solid toaster at this price.