Best Toasters at Walmart
By Annabelle Evans
| Updated 3 Days Ago
We independently review everything we recommend. When you buy through our links, we may earn a commission.
Toasters are a kitchen essential, perfect for quickly preparing breakfast or snacks by turning plain bread into crispy, golden slices in minutes. Walmart offers a wide selection of toasters to suit various needs and budgets. When choosing a toaster, consider how many slices you need to toast at once—two-slice toasters are compact and ideal for smaller households, while four-slice models are better suited for families. Other important features to look for include adjustable browning settings, wide slots for bagels, and a removable crumb tray for easy cleaning. We researched and tested popular toasters from Walmart to find the best options that offer a great balance of performance, features, and value.
Proctor Silex 4-Slice Toaster
We think this toaster is a solid choice for families or anyone who needs to toast multiple slices at once.
We think this toaster is a solid choice for families or anyone who needs to toast multiple slices at once.
We put this Proctor Silex toaster through its paces in our kitchen. The extra-wide slots came in handy when we tried toasting bagels and thick slices of homemade bread. No more cramming or squishing!
The Toast Boost feature was a nice surprise. It lifted our English muffins high enough to grab without burning our fingers. We also liked how simple it was to empty the pullout crumb tray. No more messy countertops.
We found the shade settings useful, but toasting wasn’t always even. Sometimes we had to run a second cycle for darker toast. The plastic body didn’t feel as sturdy as some pricier models we’ve tested. Still, for a budget-friendly 4-slice toaster, it got the job done.
AmazonBasics 2-Slice Toaster
We think this toaster is a solid budget pick for most people looking for a basic, reliable 2-slice model.
We think this toaster is a solid budget pick for most people looking for a basic, reliable 2-slice model.
We put this AmazonBasics toaster through its paces in our kitchen for a few weeks. Its extra-wide slots easily fit chunky artisan bread and bagels without squishing. The six browning levels let us dial in our preferred toast shade, from lightly golden to deep brown.
We liked the bagel setting, which toasts just the cut side. The frozen function was handy for defrosting bread straight from the freezer. At under $30, it’s a great value for a basic toaster that gets the job done.
The plastic exterior doesn’t feel super premium, but it stayed cool to the touch. We noticed some unevenness in browning, especially with very thin slices. The crumb tray could be deeper – we had to empty it often to avoid spills. Still, for the price, this toaster offers good performance for everyday use.
Proctor Silex Wide-Slot Toaster
We recommend this toaster for its reliable performance and user-friendly features at an affordable price.
We recommend this toaster for its reliable performance and user-friendly features at an affordable price.
This Proctor Silex toaster has been a welcome addition to our kitchen. Its wide slots easily fit our favorite artisanal breads and bagels. We found the Toast Boost feature handy for lifting smaller items like English muffins, making them easy to grab without burning our fingers.
The shade selector offers good control over toasting. We tested all 7 settings and got consistent results from light golden to dark and crispy. The cancel button came in handy when we wanted to check doneness mid-cycle.
We like how this toaster keeps our counters tidy. The pull-out crumb tray is a breeze to clean. The cord wrap in the base is a nice touch for neat storage. While it’s not the fanciest model, it does the job well and feels sturdy. For the price, we think it’s a solid choice for everyday use.
Mueller UltraToast 4-Slice
We think this toaster is a great choice for families who want even toasting and versatile options.
We think this toaster is a great choice for families who want even toasting and versatile options.
We tried out the Mueller UltraToast and were impressed by its performance. The extra-wide slots easily fit our thick-cut bread and bagels. We liked that we could toast four slices at once, which is great for busy mornings.
The six browning settings let us get our toast just right. We found the middle settings worked best for most bread types. The defrost function came in handy for frozen waffles. It warmed them up without burning the outside.
We appreciate the removable crumb tray, which makes cleaning easy. The stainless steel body looks nice on our counter too. While it’s bigger than some toasters, we think it’s worth the space if you toast a lot.
BLACK+DECKER 4-Slice Toaster
We think this toaster is a solid choice for families who want a reliable, no-frills appliance at a good price.
We think this toaster is a solid choice for families who want a reliable, no-frills appliance at a good price.
We’ve been using this BLACK+DECKER toaster for a few weeks now, and it’s a decent option for busy households. The extra-wide slots came in handy when we tried toasting bagels and artisan breads. We didn’t have to force anything in, which was nice.
The controls are simple to use. We liked the bagel and frozen settings, which adjusted the toasting time for us. The cancel button was handy when we needed to pop the toast up quickly. The lift lever is a nice touch too – it helped us grab smaller items without burning our fingers.
On the downside, we noticed some uneven browning, especially on lower settings. The outer edges of our bread sometimes came out lighter than the center. The toaster also feels a bit light, and some of the plastic parts don’t seem very sturdy. But for the price, it gets the job done. If you need a basic toaster that can handle different bread types, this one’s worth a look.
Elite Gourmet Cool Touch Toaster
We think this compact toaster is a solid choice for small kitchens and basic toasting needs.
We think this compact toaster is a solid choice for small kitchens and basic toasting needs.
We tried out the Elite Gourmet Cool Touch Toaster in our kitchen, and it’s a neat little appliance. The wide slots easily fit our bagels and thick bread slices. We liked how the outside stayed cool, so we didn’t worry about accidentally touching it.
The toaster has 6 heat settings. We played around with them to get our toast just right. It took some trial and error, but we found our sweet spot. The cancel button came in handy when we wanted to stop mid-toast.
Clean-up was a breeze thanks to the pull-out crumb tray. We did notice the toasting wasn’t always even, with the edges sometimes less browned than the center. The cord is on the short side, which limited where we could put it on our counter.
When we first used it, there was a slight plastic smell. We ran it empty a few times, and that solved the problem. Overall, it’s a basic toaster that gets the job done, especially if you’re tight on space.
BELLA 2-Slice Toaster
We recommend this affordable toaster for its versatility and user-friendly features.
We recommend this affordable toaster for its versatility and user-friendly features.
We’ve been using the BELLA 2-Slice Toaster in our test kitchen, and it’s proven to be a reliable little appliance. The wide slots easily accommodate thick bagels and artisanal bread slices, which is a big plus for breakfast lovers.
The six browning settings give us great control over our toast. We’ve found the lower settings work best for lighter breads, while denser options benefit from the higher levels. The cancel button comes in handy when we want to check on our toast mid-cycle.
One thing we really like is how compact this toaster is. It doesn’t take up much room on our crowded countertops. The removable crumb tray makes cleaning a breeze – we just slide it out and empty it over the trash can. While the plastic exterior might not feel premium, it does the job and keeps the price down.
Elite Gourmet Long Slot Toaster
We think this toaster is a solid choice for those who want versatility and even toasting at an affordable price.
We think this toaster is a solid choice for those who want versatility and even toasting at an affordable price.
We’ve been using this Elite Gourmet toaster for a while now, and it’s become a key part of our morning routine. The long slots are great for artisanal breads and Texas toast. We love that we can fit four regular slices or two long slices at once.
The six browning settings give us lots of control. We usually stick to level 3 or 4 for golden-brown toast. The defrost function works well for frozen waffles, though bagels sometimes need a second cycle to get crispy enough.
We appreciate the built-in warming rack for heating up pastries and buns. It’s a nice touch that saves counter space. The stainless steel design looks sleek in our kitchen. While the exterior does get warm, it’s not dangerously hot.
Overall, this toaster offers good value. It’s not perfect – the crumb tray feels a bit flimsy – but it does the job well for everyday use. If you’re looking for a versatile toaster that can handle different bread types, this one’s worth considering.
West Bend QuikServe Toaster
We think this toaster is a great choice for those who want fast, convenient toasting with some unique features.
We think this toaster is a great choice for those who want fast, convenient toasting with some unique features.
The West Bend QuikServe caught our eye with its speedy toasting claims, and it didn’t disappoint. We found it cranked out toast in about 90 seconds, which is perfect for busy mornings. The slide-through design is pretty nifty too. We liked how the toast comes out onto a little tray, ready to serve.
We put this toaster through its paces with different bread types. The wide slots handled thick slices and bagels like a champ. The bagel setting worked well, toasting just one side as promised. We also tried the gluten-free setting, which takes a bit longer but produced better results for gluten-free bread.
One thing to note is the power cord. It’s on the shorter side, so you might need to plan your counter space carefully. We also noticed that really large slices didn’t toast as evenly. And if you’re doing back-to-back batches, watch out – the second round tends to come out darker than the first. But for most everyday toasting needs, we found the QuikServe to be a solid performer.
Keenstone Touch Toaster
We recommend the Keenstone Touch Toaster for its intuitive controls and consistent results.
We recommend the Keenstone Touch Toaster for its intuitive controls and consistent results.
The Keenstone Touch Toaster caught our eye with its sleek design and modern touchscreen. We found the interface simple to navigate, with clear icons for bagel, defrost, and reheat functions. The 6 browning levels gave us plenty of options to get our toast just right.
We appreciated the countdown timer display, which took the guesswork out of waiting for our breakfast. The wide slots easily fit thick bagels and artisan breads without jamming. During our tests, we got evenly toasted results across different types of bread.
The stainless steel body felt sturdy and looked great on our counter. While it’s pricier than basic models, we think the Keenstone’s user-friendly features and reliable performance make it a solid choice for most kitchens. Just keep in mind it only toasts two slices at a time, which might not be enough for larger families.
Buying Guide
When shopping for a toaster at Walmart, there are a few key things to keep in mind. We’ve put together this guide to help you find the best option for your needs.
Slot Size
Consider what you’ll be toasting most often. Wide slots are great for bagels and artisan breads, while narrower slots work well for standard sliced bread.
Number of Slots
Think about how many slices you typically toast at once:
- 2-slot: Good for individuals or couples
- 4-slot: Better for families or frequent entertainers
Settings and Features
Look for adjustable browning controls to get your perfect toast. A bagel setting, defrost function, and cancel button are handy extras.
Ease of Cleaning
A removable crumb tray makes cleanup much simpler. Non-stick interiors are also easier to wipe down.
Safety
Cool-touch exteriors help prevent accidental burns. Auto shut-off is another good safety feature to look for.
Price Range
Walmart offers toasters at various price points. Here’s a general guide:
Price Range | Features |
---|---|
Under $20 | Basic 2-slot models |
$20-$50 | More features, 4-slot options |
$50+ | Premium materials, advanced functions |
We recommend balancing your budget with the features you’ll actually use. A mid-range toaster often provides the best value for most households.