Best Toasters Made in USA

We’ve been using this BLACK+DECKER toaster for a while now, and it’s a decent performer for everyday needs. The extra-wide slots are great for toasting bagels and artisan breads. We found the seven shade settings helpful for getting our toast just right.

The bagel and frozen food buttons are handy features. When we tested them, they worked well for giving our bagels a nice crisp on the cut side. The frozen setting was useful for warming up waffles straight from the freezer.

One thing we noticed is that the toaster’s plastic build feels a bit light. It might not stand up to rough handling as well as some more expensive models. We also saw some unevenness in toasting, especially on lower settings. But for the price, it’s hard to complain too much. This toaster gets the job done and looks good on the counter.

We’ve put this BLACK+DECKER 4-slice toaster through its paces in our kitchen. The extra-wide slots came in handy for toasting everything from thin sandwich bread to thick bagels. We liked being able to use just two slots when needed, saving energy for smaller batches.

The seven shade settings gave us good control over toast darkness. We found the middle settings worked best for most breads. The bagel and frozen buttons were handy features, though results weren’t always perfect. Sometimes one side toasted more than the other.

While not the fanciest toaster, it gets the job done for a good price. The slide-out crumb trays made cleanup easy. We wish the build quality felt a bit sturdier, but for basic toasting needs, this BLACK+DECKER model serves its purpose well. It’s a good pick for families on a budget who need to make lots of toast quickly.

We’ve been using this KitchenAid toaster in our test kitchen for a few weeks now. Its sleek silver design looks great on the counter. The extra-wide slots easily fit thick slices of homemade bread and bagels.

The bagel setting is a nice touch. It toasts the cut side while gently warming the outside. We found the shade control dial easy to use, with 5 settings from light to dark. Most of our toast came out just right, though we noticed some unevenness on occasion.

We like the high lift lever, which makes it easy to grab smaller items. The removable crumb tray is handy for cleaning. While it’s not the cheapest option, we think this toaster offers good value for its quality and features. It’s a step up from basic models without breaking the bank.

We tested the Mueller UltraToast and were impressed by its performance. The four extra-wide slots easily fit thick slices of artisan bread and bagels. We liked that we could toast different items at the same time.

The touch controls are simple to use. We found the LED display helpful for keeping track of toasting progress. The six browning settings let us get our toast just right, from lightly golden to dark and crispy.

Cleaning is a breeze thanks to the removable crumb tray. We appreciate the cord storage that keeps our countertop tidy. While it’s a bit large, the stainless steel design looks great in most kitchens. For families or toast lovers, we think the Mueller UltraToast is a solid pick.

We tested this GE 2-slice toaster and found it does a nice job with most bread types. The extra-wide slots easily fit bagels and Texas toast. We like the 7 shade settings, which let us dial in our preferred level of toastiness.

The illuminated buttons are a nice touch. They light up blue to show which setting you’ve picked. The removable crumb tray makes cleanup simple. Just pull it out and dump the crumbs in the trash.

One small issue we noticed was some unevenness in toasting. One side of the bread sometimes came out darker than the other. The plastic parts also felt a bit cheap to us. But for the price, we think this toaster works well for everyday use. It toasts bread, bagels, and waffles reliably. The stainless steel look fits in most kitchens too.

We tested the Hamilton Beach Modern Toaster and found it to be a solid choice for everyday use. The extra-wide slots easily fit bagels and thick slices of bread, which is a big plus. We liked how it toasted evenly most of the time, though we did notice some inconsistency on occasion.

The 7 shade settings give good control over toasting levels. We appreciated the bagel and defrost options, which came in handy for different bread types. The toast boost feature is nice for lifting smaller items, making them easier to grab.

While using it, we noticed the exterior gets quite warm. It’s not a deal-breaker, but worth being careful around. The slide-out crumb tray is a nice touch for easy cleaning. Overall, this toaster offers good value for its price point, even if some parts feel a bit less premium.

We’ve been using the Hamilton Beach Gourmet Toaster for a while now, and it’s quickly become our go-to for morning breakfasts. The Sure-Toast technology really does make a difference. We’ve noticed that both sides of our bread come out evenly browned every time, even when we’re only toasting one slice.

The extra-long slots are a game-changer for those of us who love artisan breads. We no longer have to cut our favorite sourdough loaf to fit in the toaster. The slots easily accommodate longer slices, which is a big plus in our book.

We’ve found the 7 shade settings to be very useful. Whether we’re in the mood for lightly toasted bread or a crispy bagel, this toaster delivers. The bagel setting works well too, toasting the cut side while warming the outside. Clean-up is a breeze thanks to the removable crumb tray. Overall, we’re impressed with how this toaster performs for its price point.

We’ve been using this Cuisinart 4-slice toaster in our test kitchen for weeks now. Its brushed stainless steel body looks great on the counter. The wide 1.5-inch slots easily fit bagels and thick slices of artisan bread.

We like the dual control panels that let us toast different items at the same time. The bagel, reheat, and defrost buttons come in handy. The 6 browning levels give good control, but we had to play around to find our ideal settings.

The extra-lift lever is nice for grabbing smaller items. The slide-out crumb tray makes cleanup easy. While it’s bigger than a 2-slice model, we think the added capacity is worth the space for most kitchens. It’s not the cheapest option, but the quality and features make it a good value.

We’ve been using the Elite Gourmet Long Slot Toaster for a few weeks now, and it’s quickly become a breakfast favorite. The extra-wide slots are a game-changer. We’ve toasted everything from bagels to thick slices of sourdough with ease.

The 6 different toast settings give us lots of control. We can get our toast just the way we like it, from lightly browned to dark and crunchy. The reheat function is handy too. It warms up cold toast without burning it.

One thing we really like is the built-in warming rack. It’s perfect for heating up pastries and rolls. The rack folds away when we’re not using it, which is a nice touch. The stainless steel design looks good on our counter too.

We did notice the toaster takes up more space than a standard model. But for us, the extra room is worth it for the bigger slices it can handle. The crumb tray could be a bit sturdier, but it does the job.

We’ve been using this Keenstone toaster for a while now, and it’s become a staple in our kitchen. The retro design adds a fun touch to our countertop, but it’s not just about looks. This toaster packs some serious functionality.

The extra-wide slots are a game-changer. We’ve toasted everything from thick bagels to Texas toast without any issues. The 6 browning settings let us get our toast just right, whether we prefer it lightly golden or dark and crispy.

We love the versatility of this toaster. The bagel function is great for toasting just one side, and the defrost setting comes in handy for frozen bread. The cancel button is a nice safety feature, letting us stop the toasting process if needed.